So I looked into this a little bit. Seems that this question has come up on many other forums as well. One guy who drives a tow truck said that he could track down a person's address from a license plate. I don't know about being able to steal your identity though. If that is the case, then an identity thief could go to any parking lot and jot down several license plate numbers and steal that identities that way. Again, no different than seeing a license plate on the internet.
My bike lives in my garage so I am not too worried about someone tracking my address down through my plate and stealing my bike. If I owned a rare and/or expensive vehicle like a Ferrari, then I would be more concerned.
I guess everyone has their own comfort level when it comes to stuff like this, so we each need to do what makes us comfortable.
I was in the towing industry for 30 years and that is indeed true. In most states, tow companies have access to DMV records so that they can contact owners of vehicles that they have done "non consentual" tows on.
An identity thief could, if he wanted, do just as you said, but thats not normally how they operate. The majority are internet lurkers. They spend a great deal of time on forums of all kinds, gaining as much info about someone behind the scenes as they can.
If you are a regular user af forums, it is not that difficult to built up personal knowledge of someone, locate their address and know their patterns well enough to hack into their lives. I'm not going to give any details, but that is exactl what happenend to us.
A photo of my Jeep wrangler, that had been poached off a Jeep forum was found on our thief's hard drive and was used as a piece of evidence in his trial.
Most PD's will not bother with ID theft, but we got very lucky. It ended up in Michigan and thanks to a tenatious detective, who just wouldn't quit, we got a result.
Trust me, you do not want to through it. Dont take the chance.